Best Buffalo to Indianapolis Movers + Moving Guide
Want help with the heavy lifting?
Trusted. Licensed. Insured.
If you're moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis and need first-hand information you can trust to make this 503 mile move from New York to Indiana go smoothly, Great Guys Moving is here to help. We've analyzed 23 Buffalo to Indianapolis moving companies and more than 20,000 movers nationwide to provide up-to-date and data-driven information about: which moving company to hire (our top recommendation is Bulldogs Moving Co.), how much the move costs (approximately $1,500 - $5,500 depending on how much stuff you have), and what it will be like living in Buffalo compared to Indianapolis. With a move this big, you want big data on your side and Great Guys Moving is your trusted ally to help you sift through the noise to make informed moving decisions.
Best Buffalo to Indianapolis Moving Companies
| Rank | Company Name | Rating  | Affordability Index | License | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Bulldogs Moving Co. | 9.12 | 9.47 | Authorized For HHG | Contact |
| 2 | Wayfinder Moving Services | 9.03 | 8.92 | Authorized For HHG | Contact |
| 3 | Joey Z's Moving | 8.88 | 8.66 | Active | Contact |
| 4 | Soft Touch Moving | 8.81 | 8.86 | Authorized For HHG | Contact |
| 5 | Conjerti Moving Express and Storage | 8.23 | 7.87 | Authorized For Property, HHG | Contact |
(800) 787-5428Cost to Move from Buffalo to Indianapolis
Moving a 1 bedroom apartment 503 miles from Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN will cost on average $2,209 to hire full service movers. A 3 bedroom Buffalo to Indianapolis move is roughly $5,290. See the chart below for a detailed breakdown by type of move and home size. Pricing will vary based upon the exact locations of pickup and dropoff as well as several other factors. The most important pricing component that is often overlooked is how far away the move date is. The earlier you can reserve movers, the better your pricing and options will be.
| Home Size | Moving Cost | Volume of Packed Items (ft³) | $/ft³ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $1,488 | 300 ft³ | 4.96 |
| 1 Bedroom | $2,209 | 450 ft³ | 4.91 |
| 2 Bedrooms | $3,644 | 750 ft³ | 4.86 |
| 3 Bedrooms | $5,290 | 1100 ft³ | 4.81 |
| 4 Bedrooms | $7,614 | 1600 ft³ | 4.76 |
| 5+ Bedrooms | $8,476 | 1800 ft³ | 4.71 |
Moving in the opposite direction? Here is our moving from Indianapolis to Buffalo guide.
Compare the 5 Best Buffalo to Indianapolis Movers
These are the top recommended movers based on our unbiased & regularly updated ranking algorithm (NOT paid promotions)
Bulldogs Moving Co.
Noblesville, IN, 46060
About Bulldogs Moving Co.
Bulldogs Moving Co., based in Lapel, Indiana, is a local moving company dedicated to providing high-quality services for residential and commercial...
Services
- Full-service Moves
- Packing / Unpacking
- Loading / Unloading
Interstate Moving License
USDOT / MC Status Entity Type | 3784131 / 1472268 Authorized For HHG Carrier |
| Registered Trucks/Vans | 2 |
| Registered Drivers | 6 |
| Total Annual Miles Moved | 10,000 (2021) |
Wayfinder Moving Services
75 Comet Ave
Buffalo, NY, 14216
About Wayfinder Moving Services
Established in 2018, Wayfinder Moving Services has locations in both Buffalo, NY and Jamestown. As a business that specializes in...
Services
- Cheap moving services
- Local moving services
- Long-distance moving services
Interstate Moving License
USDOT / MC Status Entity Type | 3104397 / 79366 Authorized For HHG Carrier |
| Registered Trucks/Vans | 9 |
| Registered Drivers | 9 |
| Total Annual Miles Moved | 220,000 (2022) |
Joey Z's Moving
North Tonawanda, NY, 14120
About Joey Z's Moving
Backed by over 35 years of experience, Joey Z’s Moving serves all of New York State with reliable residential and commercial...
Services
- Home & Apartment moving
- Senior Moves
- Business & Office moving
Interstate Moving License
USDOT / MC Status Entity Type | 3348965 / - Active Carrier |
| Registered Trucks/Vans | 1 |
| Registered Drivers | 2 |
| Total Annual Miles Moved | - |
Soft Touch Moving
5136b E 65th St
Indianapolis, IN, 46220
About Soft Touch Moving
Soft Touch Moving has more than 20 years in the moving and relocation industry. It has consistently provided quality full-service moving,...
Services
- Local Moving
- Long Distance Moving
- Commercial Moving
Interstate Moving License
USDOT / MC Status Entity Type | 707793 / 331362 Authorized For HHG Carrier |
| Registered Trucks/Vans | 7 |
| Registered Drivers | 7 |
| Total Annual Miles Moved | 150,000 (2023) |
Conjerti Moving Express and Storage
6707 Lincoln Ave
Lockport, NY, 14094
About Conjerti Moving Express and Storage
Conjerti Moving is a family-owned and operated business providing quality moving services to the residents of Buffalo, NY. It is highly...
Services
- Local Moving & Packing
- Cross-country Long Distance
- Corporate Office Moving & Employee Relocation
Interstate Moving License
USDOT / MC Status Entity Type | 1397261 / 574726 Authorized For Property, HHG Carrier |
| Registered Trucks/Vans | 5 |
| Registered Drivers | 3 |
| Total Annual Miles Moved | 147,261 (2021) |
Dependable Rankings You Can Count On!
Our rankings are data-driven — movers cannot purchase a spot on our list. Here's why you can have confidence in our recommendations:
- No Paid Placements: Every company earns its spot through merit, not payment.
- Extensive Analysis: Evaluated over 24,000 movers across the country for our rankings.
Dependable Rankings You Can Count On!
Our rankings are data-driven — movers cannot purchase a spot on our list. Here's why you can have confidence in our recommendations:
- No Paid Placements: Every company earns its spot through merit, not payment.
- Extensive Analysis: Evaluated over 24,000 movers across the country for our rankings.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Neighborhood Comparison
Relocating can often feel daunting, especially when moving to a city that's unfamiliar. To ease this transition, we've crafted a comparison that highlights the similar vibes and characteristics of popular neighborhoods between Buffalo, NY & Indianapolis, IN. This guide is designed to help you find a new neighborhood that feels like home.
| Buffalo | Indianapolis | How They're Similar |
|---|---|---|
| Elmwood Village | Broad Ripple | Vibrant nightlife and arts scene |
| North Buffalo | Meridian-Kessler | Historic homes, family-friendly |
| Allentown | Fountain Square | Eclectic, with a rich arts community |
| Delaware District | Old Northside | Historic district, architectural beauty |
| South Buffalo | Garfield Park | Community-oriented, with ample park space |
| West Side | Fletcher Place | Up-and-coming, with trendy eateries |
| Hertel Avenue | Mass Ave | Cultural hub, diverse dining options |
| Canalside | White River State Park | Scenic views, recreational activities |
| Parkside | Butler-Tarkington | Blend of urban and suburban, near parks |
| Waterfront | Eagle Creek | Waterfront activities, nature trails |
For those who cherish the independent boutiques and cozy cafes of Elmwood Village, Broad Ripple's bustling streets, lined with galleries, pubs, and eclectic shops, will feel like a seamless transition. Similarly, North Buffalo's family-oriented atmosphere and stately homes can be mirrored in Indianapolis' Meridian-Kessler, known for its historic charm and strong community vibes. If you're drawn to the rich cultural tapestry and vibrant nightlife of Allentown, Fountain Square offers an indie scene with unique art venues and live music, ensuring a lively locale to call home. This comparison aims to bridge the familiarity of Buffalo neighborhoods with the exciting possibilities that Indianapolis neighborhoods offer, making your move a less daunting and more exciting adventure.
Ready to start your move?
Pros and Cons of Moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis
Moving from one city to another is a major decision that involves weighing various factors to make the best choice for you and your family. This guide aims to provide an honest reflection of the good and bad attributes of relocating from Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN, helping you make an informed decision based on a comprehensive comparison of these two cities.
Buffalo, NY- Harsher winters
- Smaller city
- Higher taxes
- Less cultural diversity
Indianapolis, IN- Milder winters
- Larger city
- Lower taxes
- More cultural diversity
Indianapolis, IN- Far from landmarks
- Less intimate
- Fewer local dishes
- Younger city vibe
Buffalo, NY- Proximity to Niagara
- Close-knit community
- Unique local cuisine
- Richer history
While Indianapolis presents a compelling case with its milder winters and a more diverse cultural landscape, Buffalo boasts unique attractions like its proximity to Niagara Falls and a distinctive local cuisine celebrated across the region. Buffalo's close-knit community vibe and rich historical context create an inviting atmosphere that's hard to leave behind. However, moving to Indianapolis, you'll discover a range of new favorites among the city's thriving culinary scene, such as Milktooth for a delightful brunch or exploring the sprawling Eagle Creek Park for outdoor adventures. Not to mention, Indianapolis' larger size and lower taxes provide a broader canvas for personal and professional opportunities. The transition from Buffalo's renowned winters to Indianapolis' milder climate might also come as a pleasant change, offering a different pace of life and new experiences.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Food Guide
This is a comparison of the local cuisine between Buffalo & Indianapolis, highlighting the importance of food as a part of local culture and living experience. Through this comparison, you'll gain insights into what culinary delights await you in your new city.
| Buffalo | Indianapolis | |
|---|---|---|
| Most iconic local food item | Buffalo Wings | Pork Tenderloin Sandwich |
| Most popular meat dish | Beef on Weck | Sugar Cream Pie |
| Most popular street food item | Speidies | Corn on the Cob |
| Most popular vegan food | Tofu Wings | Seitan Steak |
| Top 3 iconic restaurants that summarize the city |
|
|
| Fitness/Health Conscientiousness | 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪 | 💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪💪 |
| Abundance of Food Trucks | 🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚 | 🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚🚚 |
| Foodie Scene | 🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴 | 🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴🍴 |
| Vegan Friendly | 🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱 | 🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱🌱 |
In Buffalo, the legendary Buffalo Wings can be savored at its birthplace, Anchor Bar, alongside other iconic restaurants like Gabriel's Gate and Duff's Famous Wings, which are central to the city's food scene. Over in Indianapolis, the Pork Tenderloin Sandwich reigns supreme with places like St. Elmo Steak House not only showcasing this local delicacy but also offering an extensive menu that captures the essence of Indianapolis dining. Indianapolis' Bluebeard restaurant presents a modern twist on local cuisine, making it a must-visit for food enthusiasts. Each city boasts a vibrant street food scene and a growing consciousness towards health and vegan options, making both destinations appealing for a variety of dietary preferences.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Restaurant Comparison
Understanding the essence of local cuisine plays a pivotal role in making a new city feel like home. This restaurant comparison aims to ease your transition by guiding you from Buffalo's beloved eateries to their counterparts in Indianapolis, helping you uncover your next favorite dining spots.
| Buffalo | Indianapolis | What You'll Love |
|---|---|---|
| Gabriel's Gate | King Dough | Authentic wood-fired pizzas reminiscent of Gabriel's Gate's charm |
| Anchor Bar | Ale Emporium | Famous for chicken wings, akin to the Anchor Bar's legendary status |
| Allen Burger Venture | Workingman's Friend | Classic, no-fuss burgers similar to Allen Burger Venture |
| Marble + Rye | Bluebeard | Innovative and upscale dining, parallel to Marble + Rye's experience |
| Lombardo Ristorante | Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant | For a homely and traditional Italian atmosphere like Lombardo's |
| Paula's Donuts | Long's Bakery | Known for their exceptional donuts, offering a taste of Paula's in Indy |
| Public Espresso + Coffee | Quills Coffee | A similar hip and quality-focused coffee scene |
| La Nova | Goodfellas Pizzeria | Both excel in creating memorable pizza experiences |
| Ted's Hot Dogs | King David Dogs | Indy's answer to classic, chargrilled hotdogs |
| Bar Bill Tavern | The Eagle | For a southern twist but with the same dedication to quality bar food |
When in search of a dining experience that brings you closer to the essence of Buffalo's vibrant food scene, Indianapolis has no shortage of comparable offerings. For example, the rustic charm and culinary innovation at Bluebeard mirrors that of Buffalo's Marble + Rye, showcasing the creativity and commitment to quality both cities share. Similarly, the heartwarming, traditional dishes served at Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant offer a nostalgic nod to the beloved Lombardo Ristorante of Buffalo, making it easier for newcomers to find comfort in familiar tastes. These establishments are not just about feeding the body but also about enriching the soul by providing experiences that resonate with the rich culinary heritage of your old hometown.
Ready to start your move?
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Real Estate & Living Facts
Real estate is one of the most critical facets when considering a move. It's vital to have a clear understanding of how the housing markets in Buffalo, NY and Indianapolis, IN stack up against each other. This comparison aims to elucidate the differences in cost , architecture , walkability , and other key aspects that can influence your decision.
| Comparison | Buffalo | Indianapolis |
|---|---|---|
| Typical Architecture Style | Victorian and Craftsman | Ranch and Colonial |
| Walkability | 👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟 | 👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟👟 |
| Bikeability | 🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲 | 🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲🚲 |
| Urban Lifestyle | 🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️ | 🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️🏛️ |
| Most popular items mentioned in real estate listing | Close to parks, Waterfront views | Spacious yards, Proximity to highways |
While the median home prices and monthly rents show Indianapolis to be slightly more expensive than Buffalo, it's important to consider what each city offers. Buffalo's architectural scene is rich with Victorian and Craftsman-style homes, often found in vibrant neighborhoods that boast a mix of urban and green spaces, such as Buffalo's historic parks. Indianapolis, on the other hand, leans more towards Ranch and Colonial styles, with many properties featuring spacious yards, a nod to its more suburban feel. Despite Buffalo having a better walkability score, indicating more amenities within walking distance, Indianapolis offers slightly better bikeability, which might appeal to those who prefer cycling over walking. Each city offers a distinct lifestyle, with Buffalo providing a more urban feel with an emphasis on waterfront and park access, while Indianapolis offers a blend of urban amenities with a more laid-back, suburban atmosphere.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Weather Considerations
When moving from Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN, it's crucial to understand how the weather compares between these two locations. This knowledge will help you adjust your lifestyle and prepare for the new environmental conditions you'll encounter. See the charts below for a detailed Buffalo vs. Indianapolis weather comparison.
Buffalo, NY
Indianapolis, IN
Average Summer High/Low (°F)
Average Summer High/Low (°F)
Buffalo, NY
Indianapolis, IN
Average Winter High/Low (°F)
Average Winter High/Low (°F)
Buffalo, NY
Indianapolis, IN
Annual Rainfall (Inches)
Annual Rainfall (Inches)
Buffalo, NY
Indianapolis, IN
Annual Snowfall (Inches)
Annual Snowfall (Inches)
| Comparison | Buffalo | Indianapolis |
|---|---|---|
| Air Quality | Good | Moderate |
| Natural Disasters | Snowstorms, Blizzards | Tornadoes, Severe Thunderstorms |
| Days of Sunshine per Year | ☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️ | ☀️☀️☀️☀️☀️ |
| Avg. UV Index | 🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️ | 🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️🕶️ |
| Avg. Annual Humidity | 💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦 | 💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦💦 |
As you can see, both Buffalo and Indianapolis offer distinct weather patterns that could influence your decision to move. Buffalo experiences harsher winters with significantly more snow, which could affect commuting or outdoor activities. In contrast, Indianapolis has more sunny days per year, which might be appealing if you enjoy spending time outdoors. However, the potential for tornadoes and severe thunderstorms in Indianapolis is something to consider. Understanding these differences will help you prepare for life in your new city, from wardrobe changes to home maintenance.
Ready to start your move?
Money, Economy, and Job Market Considerations for Moving from Buffalo to Indianapolis
Moving from one city to another can significantly impact your finances. Therefore, understanding the differences in money matters is crucial. This comparison between Buffalo, NY and Indianapolis, IN aims to highlight key financial aspects that could influence your decision to relocate.
| Comparison | Buffalo | Indianapolis |
|---|---|---|
| Avg. Household Income | $40,669 | $58,479 |
| Cost of Living Index | 95.8 | 87.2 |
| State Income Tax | 6.33 (average) | 3.23 |
| Avg. Property Tax | 2.25 | 0.85 |
| Avg. Sales Tax | 8.75 | 7.00 |
| Top 3 Industries | Healthcare, Education, Retail | Healthcare, Retail, Manufacturing |
| Affluence | Moderate | Moderate to High |
| Poverty | Significant | Moderate |
| Homelessness | Moderate | Low to Moderate |
When comparing both cities, it's noticeable that while the average household income is slightly lower in Buffalo, the cost of living and income tax rate are significantly higher in New York state compared to Indiana. However, property taxes in Buffalo are notably high, making Indianapolis an attractive place for home buyers. The sales tax difference also favors Indianapolis, albeit slightly. Both cities boast a strong presence in healthcare and retail industries, but Indianapolis has a significant manufacturing sector as well. The overall affluence and levels of poverty and homelessness indicate socioeconomic differences that could impact your lifestyle in each city.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Political & Religious Comparison
Moving from one city to another offers a unique opportunity to immerse yourself in a new environment. This quick snapshot aims to provide you with an understanding of the comparison between Buffalo & Indianapolis , focusing on the political and religious makeup of their residents.
| Buffalo | Indianapolis | |
|---|---|---|
| Political Make-up | Largely Democratic | Moderate, with both Democratic and Republican representation |
| Local Politics | Progressive policies more common | Mix of conservative and progressive policies |
| Religion | Christianity dominant, with a strong Catholic presence | Diverse religious landscape, Christianity prevalent but with a growing representation of other faiths |
In both Buffalo and Indianapolis, the political and religious climates reflect the diverse nature of their populations. Buffalo tends to lean more Democratic with a significant Catholic influence within its religious communities. In contrast, Indianapolis presents a more moderate political environment that houses a broader spectrum of religious beliefs, including a notable increase in non-Christian faiths. This diverse makeup contributes to the rich, multicultural fabric of both cities, influencing their social policies, community events, and daily life. Understanding these dynamics can help you better integrate and find your place in your new home.
Buffalo vs. Indianapolis Traffic and Public Transit Considerations
Moving from Buffalo, NY to Indianapolis, IN? This comparison of the traffic and transportation options between Buffalo & Indianapolis will help you understand what to expect in terms of your daily commute and maneuvering through traffic in your new city.
| Comparison | Buffalo | Indianapolis |
|---|---|---|
| Avg Commute Time (in minutes) | 22 | 25 |
| Traffic Congestion | 🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦 | 🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦🚦 |
| Availability of Public Transit | 🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇 | 🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇🚇 |
| Can you get by without a car? | Possible, but challenging | Difficult |
When comparing the two cities, you'll find that Buffalo offers a slightly easier commute with an average commute time that is 3 minutes less than Indianapolis. This might not seem like a lot, but it adds up quickly over a week. Buffalo's traffic congestion is also rated lower which could make for a smoother drive. However, when it comes to public transit options, Buffalo scores higher, although it's still possible but challenging to get by without a car. Indianapolis lags in this category, indicating a stronger dependence on personal vehicles for commuting and getting around. This might influence your decision on where to live or what transportation methods to rely upon in Indianapolis.
Additional Resources
Buffalo Moving Services
Popular Buffalo to Indiana Routes
Popular Moving Resources
