10 Best Movers Near Greencastle, IN

Unbiased Rankings Updated Monthly

Want help with the heavy lifting?

MoversChevron RightIndianaChevron RightGreencastle

Get a quote now.

When every moving company in Greencastle, IN claims they're the best, how do you really know? We analyzed 19 moving companies in Greencastle across 34,453 review data points and more than 15,000 movers nationwide using our 11-point rating system to help you determine the best moving company in Greencastle. See the top 10 Greencastle movers below (our top recommendation is: New City Moving), get data-based information on Greencastle moving costs (expect to pay somewhere between $743 and $1,109), or filter movers to display the cheapest movers in Greencastle, or the top recommendation for a Greencastle long distance move out of Indiana.

Best Greencastle, IN Movers Featured Image

Best Moving Companies in Greencastle, IN

RankCompany Name
Rating Question
Affordability IndexHourly MinimumAvg Move DurationContact
1New City Moving9.369.342 hours3 hoursContact
2Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc.9.028.9-3 hoursContact
3Move Indy9.029-1.5 hoursContact
4A Better Way Moving and Storage8.889.29-3.5 hoursContact
5Soft Touch Moving8.828.86--Contact
6You Move Me Indianapolis8.758.32-3 hoursContact
7Leaders Moving & Storage Co.8.699.27-3.5 hoursContact
8Colt Moving8.508.362 hours4 hoursContact
9University Moving and Storage8.328.45-6 hoursContact
10College Movers & Junk Hauling8.108.780.5 hours2 hoursContact

How Much Do Movers Cost in Greencastle, IN?

The average moving cost in Greencastle, IN is $969, which is based on an analysis from 62 customer reports across 6 different moving companies. In general, expect to pay somewhere between $743 and $1,109 for a typical move.

Company NameMedian Reported Moving CostAvg Move Duration
College Movers & Junk Hauling$4842 hours
You Move Me Indianapolis$7433 hours
New City Moving$8773 hours
Two Men and a Truck$1,0603.75 hours
Busy Bee Movers$1,1094 hours
Colt Moving$1,4054 hours
*Please be aware that the listed prices derive from historical customer feedback spanning several years and might not mirror the exact current rates of a company. Additionally, the anticipated cost range provided represents the 25th to 75th percentiles from the comprehensive reports of all Greencastle-based companies in our dataset.

Detailed 11-Point Review Analysis

We've analyzed more than 34,453 review data points to compare the top Greencastle movers across 11 important moving criteria. Here's how they stack up:

Quality iconQuality
Punctuality iconPunctuality
Affordability iconAffordability
Communication iconCommunication
Stick to Prices iconStick to Prices
Speed iconSpeed
Friendliness iconFriendliness
Will Hire Again iconWill Hire Again
Professionalism iconProfessionalism
Conflict Handling iconConflict Handling
Precision & Care iconPrecision & Care
New City Moving Logo

New City Moving

Exceptional9.36
89
90
85
87
97
96
93
85
87
94
81
Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc. Logo

Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc.

Superb9.02
84
82
64
61
94
87
95
79
90
80
77
Move Indy Logo

Move Indy

Superb9.02
87
81
68
86
92
78
81
84
76
72
90
A Better Way Moving and Storage Logo

A Better Way Moving and Storage

Superb8.88
67
69
89
65
87
84
91
68
66
77
66
Soft Touch Moving Logo

Soft Touch Moving

Superb8.82
64
59
67
83
81
67
53
68
70
85
74
You Move Me Indianapolis Logo

You Move Me Indianapolis

Superb8.75
91
86
42
74
63
95
94
91
94
55
79
Leaders Moving & Storage Co. Logo

Leaders Moving & Storage Co.

Fabulous8.69
73
71
90
64
69
77
92
77
72
53
62
Colt Moving Logo

Colt Moving

Fabulous8.50
69
64
47
67
64
48
83
68
68
59
64
University Moving and Storage Logo

University Moving and Storage

Very Good8.32
75
60
53
71
38
76
56
68
75
44
62
College Movers & Junk Hauling Logo

College Movers & Junk Hauling

Very Good8.10
65
52
72
49
29
72
85
64
62
34
47

Percentile Ranking

0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
*Note: the above data points reflect a moving company's percentile ranking compared to all moving companies in Indiana.

Compare The Top-Ranked Greencastle Movers

These are the top recommended movers based on our unbiased & regularly updated ranking algorithm (NOT paid promotions)

New City Moving Logo

New City Moving

Exceptional9.36/10
based on 15,054+ data points

2929 N Campbell Ave

Chicago, IL, 60618

About New City Moving

With more than a thousand excellent reviews on Google alone, New City Moving is the epitome of what a first-class moving...

Services

  • Local Moving
  • Intra-State Moving
  • Business Moving
  • Short-Term and Long-Term Storage
  • Professional Packing Services
  • Loading and Unloading
  • Office and Commercial Moving
  • Moving Company Protection & Insurance
  • Full Service Storage
  • Mobile Storage In Chicago

Pros

  • Exceptional service and efficiency throughout the move
  • Professional and friendly team, highlighted by specific praises for individuals
  • Accurate and reasonable quotes, with many reports of final costs being lower
  • High level of care in packing and transporting belongings

Cons

  • Additional charges not clearly communicated
  • Significant delays in resolving issues or offering compensation for damages
  • Unprofessional behavior and poor customer service post-move
  • Rare instances of damaged items and inadequate follow-up

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT4020807Authorized For HHG1/9/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
1
Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc. Logo

Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc.

Superb9.02/10
based on 1,298+ data points

530 N Meridian St

Greenwood, IN, 46143

About Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc.

As a locally owned and operated moving company based in the Indianapolis area, Greenwood Moving and Storage has been helping people...

Services

  • Residential Moving
  • Office & Corporate Relocation
  • Storage Containers on Wheels
  • Packing & Shipping Kits
  • Furniture & Home Protection
  • Cheap Moving Rates
  • Small Moving Services
  • Last-Minute Moving
  • Hourly Moving Services
  • Commercial Moving Services

Pros

  • Professional and efficient
  • Friendly and respectful staff
  • On-time and punctual
  • Cost-effective and offers fair pricing

Cons

  • Rare instances of delays or inefficiency
  • Occasional communication issues
  • Infrequent cases of damage or mishandling
  • Sporadic issues with not meeting appointment commitments

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT265315Authorized For Property1/9/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
2
Move Indy Logo

Move Indy

Superb
claimed company icon
9.02/10
based on 584+ data points

103 E Lincoln St

Danville, IN, 46122

About Move Indy

Move Indy is a family-owned and operated moving company based in Indianapolis, Indiana. It has years of experience in the moving...

Phone Call Now

Services

  • Moving
  • Packing
  • Storage
  • Junk Removal
  • Cleaning

Pros

  • Efficient and quick service
  • Professional and friendly teams
  • Excellent communication throughout the process
  • Cost-effective, often coming in below estimate

Cons

  • Issues with unprofessional management in some cases
  • Occasional damage to items, like a dented deep freezer
  • Some reports of poor follow-up and service correction
  • Infrequent logistical issues, such as arrival delays
Read Our Detailed Review
3
A Better Way Moving and Storage Logo

A Better Way Moving and Storage

Superb8.88/10
based on 1,120+ data points

4801 W Vernal Pike

Bloomington, IN, 47404

About A Better Way Moving and Storage

A Better Way Moving and Storage is a family-owned and operated moving company with more than 30 years of experience. It’s...

Services

  • Local Moving
  • Long Distance Moving
  • Packing
  • Pianos
  • Load and Unloading Services
  • Trucks
  • Labor only Rates
  • Dollies and tools
  • Fuel Related Charge
  • Frequently Asked Questions

Pros

  • Professional and courteous crew
  • Efficient and quick moving process
  • Careful handling of belongings with no reported damages
  • Arrived on time or early for moves

Cons

  • Rare reports of communication issues
  • Infrequent incidents of delayed delivery
  • Occasional issues with responsiveness
  • Some cases of unexpected charges
Read Our Detailed Review
4
Soft Touch Moving Logo

Soft Touch Moving

Superb8.82/10
based on 174+ data points

5136b E 65th St

Indianapolis, IN, 46220

About Soft Touch Moving

Soft Touch Moving has more than 20 years in the moving and relocation industry. It has consistently provided quality full-service moving,...

Services

  • Local Moving
  • Long Distance Moving
  • Commercial Moving
  • Relocation Consultation
  • Storage Solutions
  • Long-term and short-term storage
  • Crating
  • Warehousing and receiving
  • Packing Solutions
  • Pre-Move Pack

Pros

  • Reasonably priced
  • Friendly and professional team
  • Efficient in moving process
  • Great customer service and communication

Cons

  • Some cases of damaged items but with offered compensation

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT707793Authorized For HHG5/20/2024
Read Our Detailed Review
5
You Move Me Indianapolis Logo

You Move Me Indianapolis

Superb8.75/10
based on 1,372+ data points

Speedway, IN, 46224

About You Move Me Indianapolis

You Move Me Indianapolis is a professional moving company founded in September 2012 with the goal of revolutionizing the local moving...

Services

  • Local Moving
  • Senior Moving
  • Premium Long Distance Moving
  • Commercial Moving

Pros

  • Professional and courteous crew
  • Efficient and quick move
  • Handled items with care
  • Competitive pricing with no hidden fees

Cons

  • Arrived an hour late in some cases
  • Rare cases of damaged items
  • Some instances hard to get a hold of or poor response to voicemails
  • Occasional reports of the final cost being significantly higher than quoted

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT3821121Authorized For HHG1/10/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
6
Leaders Moving & Storage Co. Logo

Leaders Moving & Storage Co.

Fabulous8.69/10
based on 4,010+ data points

9900 Westpoint Dr # 120

Indianapolis, IN, 46256

About Leaders Moving & Storage Co.

This long-standing moving company is one of the largest in the Midwest with locations in Indianapolis, IN and Richmond, IN, as...

Services

Pros

  • Professional and courteous team
  • Efficient and quick moving process
  • Reasonable and competitive pricing
  • Good attention to detail and careful handling

Cons

  • Rare cases of items being damaged
  • Some incidents of slow communication
  • Occasional issues with unprofessional conduct
  • Infrequent cases of additional charges for unlisted items
Read Our Detailed Review
7
Colt Moving Logo

Colt Moving

Fabulous8.50/10
based on 3,793+ data points

Bittner Way

Noblesville, IN, 46062

About Colt Moving

Locally owned and operated Colt Moving provides moving services throughout the Indianapolis, Indiana area, including Carmel, Greenwood, and more. With an...

Services

  • Local and long distance moving
  • Commercial moving
  • Residential moving
  • Furniture assembly
  • Truck, pod, and ABF trailer loading and unloading
  • Specialty item moving (such as pianos, pool tables, and appliances)
  • Dumping and hauling services
  • Packing services
  • Storage services
  • Hourly moving services

Pros

  • courteous and friendly staff
  • efficient with items and time
  • professional and comprehensive service
  • careful with furniture and belongings

Cons

  • overspent and felt extremely expensive
  • antique items got damaged
  • lack of response to complaints and issues
  • packing decisions and practices were poor

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT3072091Not Authorized1/9/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
8
University Moving and Storage Logo

University Moving and Storage

Very Good8.32/10
based on 547+ data points

3881 Perry Blvd

Whitestown, IN, 46075

About University Moving and Storage

Founded in 1969, University Moving and Storage is a long-running professional moving company that provides moving services in multiple states, including...

Services

  • Residential Movers
  • Commercial Movers
  • International Movers
  • Corporate Relocation Movers
  • Storage Solutions
  • Logistics Services
  • Senior Moving

Pros

  • Efficient and quick moving process
  • Professional and courteous team
  • Excellent communication and updates
  • Packing and handling with care

Cons

  • Additional charges beyond initial estimate
  • Slow to address issues and follow up on claims
  • Damage to furniture and property
  • Experience of fraud and overcharge concerns

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT438382Authorized For HHG9/14/2021
Read Our Detailed Review
9
College Movers & Junk Hauling Logo

College Movers & Junk Hauling

Very Good8.10/10
based on 2,505+ data points

3826, 2620 N Walnut St suite 370

Bloomington, IN, 47408

About College Movers & Junk Hauling

College Movers & Junk Hauling is a fully licensed and insured moving company that offers affordable moving and junk removal services....

Services

  • Local & Long Distance Moving
  • Licensed & Insured Moving Services
  • Piano Moving
  • Furniture Disassembly & Reassembly
  • Full-Service Moves
  • Junk Removal
  • Furniture & Appliance Pickup
  • Appliance & Electronic Recycling
  • Dumpster Roll Off Rentals
  • Affordable Rates

Pros

  • Efficient and speedy service
  • Professional and courteous crew
  • Reasonable and sometimes below-expected costs
  • Flexible and accommodating scheduling

Cons

  • Some reports of damaged items
  • Occasional late arrivals and delays
  • Rare instances of billing discrepancies
  • Infrequent poor communication and customer support

Moving License

License TypeNumberStatusLast Verified
USDOT3008354Not Authorized1/10/2025
Read Our Detailed Review
10
Rankings You Can Trust background image
Trust Rankings icon

Dependable Rankings You Can Count On!

Our rankings are data-driven — movers cannot purchase a spot on our list. Here's why you can have confidence in our recommendations:

  • No Paid Placements: Every company earns its spot through merit, not payment.
  • Extensive Analysis: Evaluated over 24,000 movers across the country for our rankings.
How we review icon

How do we review a moving company?

Imagine the challenge of sifting through and reading every single review a moving company has ever received. Could you spot the fake reviews? Could you formulate a well-rounded analyses, or would you be left relying on a gut feeling?

Our rigorous evaluation process addresses this by meticulously vetting each moving company based on 11 crucial aspects of the moving experience:

  • 1. Quality

    Overall quality of the service provided on moving day.

  • 2. Punctuality

    Did the crew show up on-time with the required equipment?

  • 3. Affordability

    1 = extremely expensive, 10 = extremely affordable

  • 4. Communication

    Was the office staff quick to respond to questions prior to moving day? Did the moving crew notify you on the day of move regarding any changes to the original schedule? If there were any issues to resolve after moving day, was an office manager quick to respond and address problems encountered?

  • 5. Stick to Prices

    Was a lowball quote provided to earn business only to see the final moving day price increase substantially?

  • 6. Speed

    Did the movers seem to take their precious time in an attempt to increase the overall cost of the move? Remember, moving is HARD work and some breaks should be expected!

  • 7. Friendliness

    Was the moving crew cordial and friendly to be around on moving day?

  • 8. Will Hire Again

    How likely a customer is to hire the same movers again for their next move.

  • 9. Professionalism

    Did the moving crew behave in a professional manner on moving day?

  • 10. Conflict Handling

    Accidents can and will likely happen at some point on moving day. How a moving company responds to these accidents can say a lot about the company.

  • 11. Precision & Care

    Were walls scratched? Did furniture get scuffed, broken, or lost?

List of All Greencastle Moving Companies Analyzed

See all of our Greencastle moving company reviews
  • New City Moving
  • Leaders Moving & Storage Co.
  • Busy Bee Movers
  • Colt Moving
  • Greenwood Moving & Storage, Inc.
  • University Moving and Storage
  • Commercial Works Moving & Storage
  • U-Pack
  • PODS Moving & Storage
  • Move Indy
  • Soft Touch Moving
  • Two Men and a Truck
  • College Movers & Junk Hauling
  • A Better Way Moving and Storage
  • Sappington & Sons Moving Inc
  • H and G Movers
  • College Movers & Junk Hauling
  • 1-800-PACK-RAT Moving and Storage
  • You Move Me Indianapolis

Why Hire Leaders Moving & Storage Co.

You should hire Leaders Moving & Storage Co. for a move if you're looking for a professional and reliable moving company. Many customers have praised the movers for being friendly, efficient, and careful with their belongings. The front office staff is also commended for their communication and customer service skills. Additionally, the company is known for its flexible services and competitive pricing. Despite some negative reviews, many customers have had positive experiences with Leaders Moving & Storage Co. and would recommend them to others.

View Full Profile >>
CTA background image

Hire better movers!

Make an easier move.
Best Greencastle, IN Movers Featured Image